The 2006 Scouting Report by the Fans for the Fans

2006 The Scouting Report, By the Fans, For the Fans

Player Pos Overall
Position-Neutral Instincts FirstStep Speed Hands Release Strength Accuracy Ballots Agreement
Level
Rodriguez, Ivan C 82 83 78 62 79 98 92 94 58 0.82
Mauer, Joe C 80 84 69 64 87 92 89 88 39 0.85
Olivo, Miguel C 73 73 76 77 47 82 88 81 7 0.69
Laird, Gerald C 68 67 62 65 61 76 76 77 12 0.65
Martin, Russell C 67 72 67 48 70 73 72 67 12 0.69
Hernandez, Ramon C 62 68 40 35 62 85 87 80 19 0.59
Matheny, Mike C 61 64 50 23 85 83 60 73 25 0.66
Ausmus, Brad C 60 76 53 36 83 63 43 50 15 0.56
Blanco, Henry C 59 64 34 24 79 82 79 75 27 0.65
Molina, Yadier C 59 61 31 20 69 88 92 94 41 0.67
Kendall, Jason C 58 73 56 58 68 55 36 41 42 0.55
Molina, Jose C 57 56 41 26 61 81 79 83 8 0.65
Wilson, Vance C 56 61 48 35 64 67 60 63 46 0.72
Ardoin, Danny C 56 66 36 23 61 79 74 70 7 0.53
Varitek, Jason C 56 70 50 42 70 58 46 50 106 0.68
Treanor, Matt C 55 62 38 32 69 67 64 66 7 0.59
LaRue, Jason C 55 61 54 35 36 69 74 72 25 0.63
Snyder, Chris C 55 62 34 30 65 69 72 70 18 0.74
Shoppach, Kelly C 55 54 38 32 60 73 75 75 16 0.78
Schneider, Brian C 55 57 48 32 65 71 64 54 15 0.61
Ruiz, Carlos C 53 47 41 50 69 48 64 58 7 0.63
Redmond, Mike C 52 63 34 26 65 64 59 66 25 0.76
McCann, Brian C 52 65 36 29 68 60 58 53 10 0.69
Bard, Josh C 50 61 48 47 55 46 45 34 6 0.8
Posada, Jorge C 50 50 39 22 53 69 67 68 46 0.61
Johjima, Kenji C 49 54 45 39 45 58 57 54 176 0.65
Bowen, Rob C 49 34 48 50 55 48 61 54 3 0.82
Napoli, Mike C 49 52 45 42 52 53 57 39 9 0.62
Coste, Chris C 48 48 35 37 54 53 59 65 12 0.64
Castro, Ramon C 48 45 35 31 53 61 68 59 11 0.58
Navarro, Dioner C 47 56 40 31 48 51 59 49 12 0.73
Barajas, Rod C 47 38 25 20 67 71 68 63 13 0.63
Miller, Damian C 46 60 27 24 60 53 51 54 17 0.77
Mathis, Jeff C 46 43 56 50 28 41 54 49 3 0.17
Buck, John C 45 51 30 27 55 55 58 53 14 0.61
Pierzynski, A.J. C 44 53 39 27 55 45 44 40 30 0.7
Estrada, Johnny C 44 44 26 25 57 59 60 59 19 0.58
Hall, Toby C 42 38 24 19 60 56 54 59 6 0.58
Lo Duca, Paul C 41 58 44 33 40 36 30 35 23 0.45
Rivera, Mike C 40 45 40 34 38 38 41 44 11 0.62
Torrealba, Yorvit C 40 43 36 25 36 50 57 46 11 0.69
Zaun, Gregg C 39 44 32 32 49 41 37 39 42 0.72
Mirabelli, Doug C 38 42 23 18 54 46 50 45 81 0.69
Bako, Paul C 36 43 19 29 45 46 41 39 5 0.61
Paulino, Ronny C 36 31 27 24 30 48 62 46 21 0.64
Barrett, Michael C 36 36 41 39 27 31 39 35 37 0.61
Pratt, Todd C 36 36 17 13 58 48 41 54 4 0.6
Bennett, Gary C 35 39 25 22 45 37 40 48 15 0.76
Cota, Humberto C 35 33 29 27 38 46 43 41 11 0.62
Alfonzo, Eliezer C 35 35 42 23 34 25 45 42 28 0.62
Melhuse, Adam C 34 36 27 27 32 41 45 44 22 0.69
Rivera, Rene C 33 32 27 25 35 37 46 35 123 0.63
Lieberthal, Mike C 33 41 22 18 45 41 35 28 15 0.7
Ross, David C 33 39 34 29 23 36 39 34 24 0.77
Fasano, Sal C 32 40 18 19 49 27 46 33 10 0.64
Moeller, Chad C 31 28 29 27 38 32 28 35 13 0.61
Ojeda, Miguel C 31 43 9 12 42 41 36 45 5 0.53
Munson, Eric C 29 33 24 29 24 32 39 27 10 0.66
Paul, Josh C 27 16 36 29 21 11 41 39 2 0.5
Valentin, Javier C 25 25 20 20 27 24 33 32 19 0.75
Martinez, Victor C 25 46 18 14 53 0 18 7 25 0.67
Molina, Bengie C 25 24 8 9 32 37 44 40 49 0.69
Fick, Robert C 24 25 30 29 28 17 12 18 8 0.76
Alomar Jr., Sandy C 24 28 13 17 32 34 35 8 8 0.74
Piazza, Mike C 24 49 12 13 55 18 0 0 12 0.75
Widger, Chris C 21 22 27 26 23 15 15 13 13 0.57
Closser, JD C 20 24 24 40 10 0 28 4 7 0.62
Greene, Todd C 20 27 24 13 15 27 17 14 17 0.67
Lopez, Javy C 17 34 10 16 15 11 15 11 9 0.72
Stinnett, Kelly C 17 16 17 15 27 18 15 8 12 0.66
Gonzalez, Wiki C 5 0 4 8 0 5 20 8 5 0.79
LeCroy, Matthew C 2 0 2 8 0 0 0 0 10 0.9

Final: Nov 30, 2006

The league average for each of the seven traits of fielding is fixed at 50, with one standard deviation equal to 20 points. This means that a player with a trait value of 70 is in the top 16% in the league.

A player's name in gray means the player received less than 3 votes. A player's name in red received less than 6 votes.

The higher the agreement level, the more that the fans agreed with each other in the balloting. The league average is .71. The league low is around .40.

Player	Pos	Overall Position-Neutral	Instincts	FirstStep	Speed	Hands	Release	Strength	Accuracy	Ballots	Agreement Level
Rodriguez, Ivan	C	82	83	78	62	79	98	92	94	58	0.82
Mauer, Joe	C	80	84	69	64	87	92	89	88	39	0.85
Olivo, Miguel	C	73	73	76	77	47	82	88	81	7	0.69
Laird, Gerald	C	68	67	62	65	61	76	76	77	12	0.65
Martin, Russell	C	67	72	67	48	70	73	72	67	12	0.69
Hernandez, Ramon	C	62	68	40	35	62	85	87	80	19	0.59
Matheny, Mike	C	61	64	50	23	85	83	60	73	25	0.66
Ausmus, Brad	C	60	76	53	36	83	63	43	50	15	0.56
Blanco, Henry	C	59	64	34	24	79	82	79	75	27	0.65
Molina, Yadier	C	59	61	31	20	69	88	92	94	41	0.67
Kendall, Jason	C	58	73	56	58	68	55	36	41	42	0.55
Molina, Jose	C	57	56	41	26	61	81	79	83	8	0.65
Wilson, Vance	C	56	61	48	35	64	67	60	63	46	0.72
Ardoin, Danny	C	56	66	36	23	61	79	74	70	7	0.53
Varitek, Jason	C	56	70	50	42	70	58	46	50	106	0.68
Treanor, Matt	C	55	62	38	32	69	67	64	66	7	0.59
LaRue, Jason	C	55	61	54	35	36	69	74	72	25	0.63
Snyder, Chris	C	55	62	34	30	65	69	72	70	18	0.74
Shoppach, Kelly	C	55	54	38	32	60	73	75	75	16	0.78
Schneider, Brian	C	55	57	48	32	65	71	64	54	15	0.61
Ruiz, Carlos	C	53	47	41	50	69	48	64	58	7	0.63
Redmond, Mike	C	52	63	34	26	65	64	59	66	25	0.76
McCann, Brian	C	52	65	36	29	68	60	58	53	10	0.69
Bard, Josh	C	50	61	48	47	55	46	45	34	6	0.8
Posada, Jorge	C	50	50	39	22	53	69	67	68	46	0.61
Johjima, Kenji	C	49	54	45	39	45	58	57	54	176	0.65
Bowen, Rob	C	49	34	48	50	55	48	61	54	3	0.82
Napoli, Mike	C	49	52	45	42	52	53	57	39	9	0.62
Coste, Chris	C	48	48	35	37	54	53	59	65	12	0.64
Castro, Ramon	C	48	45	35	31	53	61	68	59	11	0.58
Navarro, Dioner	C	47	56	40	31	48	51	59	49	12	0.73
Barajas, Rod	C	47	38	25	20	67	71	68	63	13	0.63
Miller, Damian	C	46	60	27	24	60	53	51	54	17	0.77
Mathis, Jeff	C	46	43	56	50	28	41	54	49	3	0.17
Buck, John	C	45	51	30	27	55	55	58	53	14	0.61
Pierzynski, A.J.	C	44	53	39	27	55	45	44	40	30	0.7
Estrada, Johnny	C	44	44	26	25	57	59	60	59	19	0.58
Hall, Toby	C	42	38	24	19	60	56	54	59	6	0.58
Lo Duca, Paul	C	41	58	44	33	40	36	30	35	23	0.45
Rivera, Mike	C	40	45	40	34	38	38	41	44	11	0.62
Torrealba, Yorvit	C	40	43	36	25	36	50	57	46	11	0.69
Zaun, Gregg	C	39	44	32	32	49	41	37	39	42	0.72
Mirabelli, Doug	C	38	42	23	18	54	46	50	45	81	0.69
Bako, Paul	C	36	43	19	29	45	46	41	39	5	0.61
Paulino, Ronny	C	36	31	27	24	30	48	62	46	21	0.64
Barrett, Michael	C	36	36	41	39	27	31	39	35	37	0.61
Pratt, Todd	C	36	36	17	13	58	48	41	54	4	0.6
Bennett, Gary	C	35	39	25	22	45	37	40	48	15	0.76
Cota, Humberto	C	35	33	29	27	38	46	43	41	11	0.62
Alfonzo, Eliezer	C	35	35	42	23	34	25	45	42	28	0.62
Melhuse, Adam	C	34	36	27	27	32	41	45	44	22	0.69
Rivera, Rene	C	33	32	27	25	35	37	46	35	123	0.63
Lieberthal, Mike	C	33	41	22	18	45	41	35	28	15	0.7
Ross, David	C	33	39	34	29	23	36	39	34	24	0.77
Fasano, Sal	C	32	40	18	19	49	27	46	33	10	0.64
Moeller, Chad	C	31	28	29	27	38	32	28	35	13	0.61
Ojeda, Miguel	C	31	43	9	12	42	41	36	45	5	0.53
Munson, Eric	C	29	33	24	29	24	32	39	27	10	0.66
Paul, Josh	C	27	16	36	29	21	11	41	39	2	0.5
Valentin, Javier	C	25	25	20	20	27	24	33	32	19	0.75
Martinez, Victor	C	25	46	18	14	53	0	18	7	25	0.67
Molina, Bengie	C	25	24	8	9	32	37	44	40	49	0.69
Fick, Robert	C	24	25	30	29	28	17	12	18	8	0.76
Alomar Jr., Sandy	C	24	28	13	17	32	34	35	8	8	0.74
Piazza, Mike	C	24	49	12	13	55	18	0	0	12	0.75
Widger, Chris	C	21	22	27	26	23	15	15	13	13	0.57
Closser, JD	C	20	24	24	40	10	0	28	4	7	0.62
Greene, Todd	C	20	27	24	13	15	27	17	14	17	0.67
Lopez, Javy	C	17	34	10	16	15	11	15	11	9	0.72
Stinnett, Kelly	C	17	16	17	15	27	18	15	8	12	0.66
Gonzalez, Wiki	C	5	0	4	8	0	5	20	8	5	0.79
LeCroy, Matthew	C	2	0	2	8	0	0	0	0	10	0.9