Home

The Best Baseball Movies Matchup

By the Fans, For the Fans

In partnership with Baseball Movies, this project is simple: you will be presented with two baseball movies at a time, and you simply have to indicate which you prefer. The head-to-head results are collected, with final results presented in the near future. The complete list of movies can be found here.

 

If you have NOT SEEN BOTH, then simply select Pass, and you'll be presented with another random pair of baseball movies.

 

 

1. The Fan
Dark, slick psychological thriller/horror about psychotic fan's obsession with star ballplayer. Character development buffs are sorely disappointed, but over-the-top plot developments create solid entertainment for fans of ominous, stalker-oriented thrillers. -1996
2. The Scout
Mood-swinging baseball movie about talent scout discovering teen phenomenon starts out as light comedy, abruptly becomes deeply sentimental drama. Best reserved for true baseball fans, due to its abundant baseball cameos. (1994)

I HAVE seen both, and the better baseball movie is:

1. The Fan
2. The Scout
3. Pass and rank two other scenarios